As in our recent posts, we feel this is yet another instance that makes our point. Disparity of wealth, power, and justice. There are guilty individuals in a variety of situations. But punishment and the application of “justice” seems more problematic than a solution. Instead it points out the unequal hand of justice, that one cannot depend on a uniform rule of law. Who is guilty, who is responsible, and who will be blamed too often seems to be politically motivated, rather than a democratic application of laws, particularly when it comes to systemic issues.
This is about Russia, but we see much of the same in the US, and use this as some reflection on the handling of Bradley Manning. The US military recruits individuals like Manning, selling them and their families on the idea that they will be part of “something bigger than themselves” – often appealing to those who may be naive or need to fulfill esteem, leave the back door wide open for trouble (unconscionable lack of security in this case) – and then blame the individual. Manning may go to jail for the rest of his life; but too many generals are taking jobs in the military-industrial complex. It’s a set up for resentment. The individual will pay a price, but the system that created will go on, and the history of these incidents will repeat themselves.
The comments by these Russians are telling, about their system – and we think much in the US too.
From the BBC and readers’ comments:
“Khodorkovsky verdict: Views from Russia
Former Russian oil tycoon Mikhail Khodorkovsky has been found guilty of embezzlement at his second trial in Moscow.
Mikhail Khodorkovsky awaiting today’s verdict in the Moscow court Khodorkovsky will appeal against the verdict, his lawyers say
Khodorkovsky is already serving an eight-year sentence for fraud and tax evasion from his 2005 trial. His supporters maintain the case against him is politically motivated.
BBC Russian and BBC News website readers in Russia have been sending in their reaction to the verdict and what it means for the country.
“It is not a bad thing he is in jail. But it is a bad thing others like him are not Sergei M, St Petersburg”
“I totally agree with the guilty verdict. Khodorkovsky’s supporters want the worst for Russia. I don’t understand why Khodorkovsky should have had the privilege of producing oil (which should belong to the nation), making huge profits from it and then pulling fraudulent schemes to make those profits even bigger. Those rich people can never have enough. Vadim, Moscow”
“We shouldn’t fool ourselves, Khodorkovsky is no saint. But then most Russian businessmen, or at least the oligarchs, who started out in business in the 1990s, could be jailed on the same grounds. So this verdict to me is yet another proof of the fact that there is no justice in Russia, the courts have become a tool to be manipulated by the powers that be. As for Russia’s image, a country where there is no rule of law, it is not very attractive for investors. Mikhalych, Moscow”
“It is not a bad thing that Khodorkovsky is in jail. But it is a bad thing that others like him are not in jail. Sergei M, St Petersburg”
“There is no rule of law in Russia. But will this guilty verdict affect Russia’s image abroad? I don’t think so. The west is continuing to court Russia’s duumvirate [President Dmitry Medvedev and Prime Minister Vladimir Putin]. Svetlana Terskaya, Kandalaksha, Murmansk Region”
“I had expected this verdict. It symbolizes the strained relations between the authorities and business. Business knows what the authorities can do to it and will not contest their decisions. As for Russia’s image, nothing will happen to it. Thanks to PR, Russia can project an image it chooses to project to the West. Vladimir Okhota, Perm”
“I consider Khodorkovsky a victim of political repression. If he is guilty, he is no more guilty than other politicians and businessmen in Russia. Law should be the same for everyone. Yevgeny, St Petersburg”
“For me this is the final disappointment. Hope, of which Russian patriot Mikhail Khodorkovsky spoke, has been extinguished. I want to learn a foreign language and leave Russia as soon as possible. And take my family with me. Ivan, St Petersburg”
“It’s a verdict on Putin, not on Khodorkovsky. For Russia this means there’s no lawful way to protect yourself against Putin and his huge pyramid. Unfortunately this opens too many law-breaking ways. If people can’t find protection in courts, they have to protect themselves on their own. Interestingly enough, no single Russian media has this news. No media is left uncontrolled. Alexander Lazarev, Troitsk”
“The verdict is not a surprise for me but still I have been very upset and angry. Even for me who is not sophisticated in jurisprudence it is clear that this court has little to do with law and the prosecution is politically motivated. For Russia this is likely to mean more years of lack of political and economic competition, lawlessness and corruption growth. Igor Alyoshin, Novosibirsk”
“I’d set Khodorkovsky free whether he is to blame or not. Really, he has had enough spending behind bars, seven-plus years. I fully support the expression “a thief belongs in prison”, but the question is why all other tycoons-cum-thieves are still free and happy? It is no secret that so-called oligarchs in Russia have become rich through stealing, all kind of embezzlement or patronage of the powers that be. All they plus those who initiated the rapacious privatization here in Russia should have been put in prisoner’s box next to Mikhail Khodorkovsky and Platon Lebedev. Alex, Moscow”
The Queen